It made me think of Grandma Harriet. I think she's 82. Maybe she's 83. I should know. And I should call her.
Eighty-two points from Kobe against the Toronto Raptors made Laker fans think this face was cool and helped them dismiss all alleged transgressions from Eagle, Colorado.
1982 reminds me of the first Super Bowl I can recall. Joe Montana and the 49ers beating the Bengals in Super Bowl 16 in Detroit, well, Pontiac, Michigan.
1982 also brought us E.T. and Survivor's, "Eye of the Tiger."
But in the wine world, an 82 rating is a death sentence. I think I could grow grapes in my back yard, barrel them in the garage and score at least an 82. That rating says, "Your wine sucks. Stop making it." To me, at least.
I realize Wine Spectator's 100-Point scale states that 80-84 is considered, "Good: a solid, well-made wine," which I interpret to mean, "Do Not Buy."
Yesterday I excitedly read the new Spectator article, "Zinfandel Elegance," which raved about the 2009 Zins, many of which came from Paso Robles. I was also excited to see a free list of prices and scores of all the Zins they tasted, wondering if any of the great Zins we tried on our trip made the cut. I skimmed through, noticing plenty we tried and then stopped dead in my tracks on the M's.
There, sitting at 82 points was Minassian-Young's 2009 Estate Zinfandel. Double take. Yep, 82.
Minassian-Young 2009 Estate Zinfandel ($24)
We tasted that wine, loved it, and bought it. It was resting comfortably on the top rack of the wine fridge. Top shelf! Having already made the decision to grill steaks for dinner, I knew what wine I'd be pairing them with; an 82 point Zin. Either my mind went all Ghetto Boys on me in Paso, or Wine Spectator nailed it and I'm lucky I didn't break it out with company because it would have been an embarrassment.
Judgement time. I passed Beth's glass to her, she smelled it, then sipped it and let out a moan that may have sounded inappropriately personal if I weren't talking about a fantastic bottle of wine. It had that distinctive Paso-earthy smell, a wonderful burst of flavors and a long, peppery, super smooth finish. I will say, I thought it was a tad on the sweet side of Zins, almost Port-ish but there was nothing just "good" about it. It was awesome.
You could say ratings don't matter, and on one hand they don't. But just like thinking your college football team's gonna contend for a national championship and then see them ranked 22nd in the preseason poll, it can be a bit of a letdown. I would've absolutely been swayed away from any wine with an 82 rating, so no doubt, Minassian-Young will feel it in the sales department too. And that's a shame because they make great stuff and they are two of the nicest people in the biz that I've met. I demand a re-taste!
Offical Grade: B+
Beth's Grade: A-